The Problem with LegalZoom (And Other Do-It-Yourself Estate Planning Solutions)

RISKLegalZoom advertises itself as a cheaper alternative to an attorney. And many forgo professional advice because they are lured by the lower costs and believe the document LegalZoom creates will be just as effective as one created by an attorney. Having heard so much about LegalZoom, I recently visited its website.

At first glance, the LegalZoom site looked like it provided state-specific advice regarding Texas wills.  And had I not been a Texas lawyer who focuses on estate planning, I might have trusted that the site was providing me with accurate and current information.

But a few moments after I started reading LegalZoom’s website copy, I noticed a couple of glaring mistakes.

Estate planning laws change

Laws are not static. They constantly change because of new case law and statutes. And lawyers keep up with these changes in order to best advise their clients. LegalZoom? Not so much.

The first mistake I noticed concerned LegalZoom’s statement about oral wills. According to LegalZoom, Texas recognizes oral wills. legalzoom oral
LegalZoom is apparently not aware that effective September 1, 2007, Texas repealed Sections 64 and 65 of the Probate Code, which authorized oral wills. Under the current state of the law, Texas will not recognize an oral will unless it was made before September 1, 2007, and even then, only in very limited circumstances.

Another mistake I noticed was under the subheading “Providing for Pets.” LegalZoom stated the following:legalzoom pets LegalZoom is apparently also not aware that effective January 1, 2006, Texas enacted Section 112.037 of the Property Code which authorizes statutory pet trusts. This means that even though four years have passed since the statute was enacted, LegalZoom is still not aware of this change in the law.

Furthermore, even before statutory pet trusts were authorized, it was still possible for a pet owner to create a traditional trust to provide for a pet. A traditional trust provides for pet care indirectly by instructing a trustee to cover expenses incurred by the pet’s caretaker, the actual beneficiary of a trust, as long as the pet is cared for properly. Nowhere does LegalZoom mention this.

Details matter in estate planning

Now you may be thinking that I am blowing these little mistakes a bit out of proportion. After all, one of them concerned pets. And no one uses LegalZoom to make an oral will, so that is a harmless error.

But if LegalZoom is not current on laws about these two issues, what else has it missed? How can anyone who uses LegalZoom trust that the legal document he or she creates will do what it is supposed to do?

LegalZoom does not provide legal advice

LegalZoom does not purport to give legal advice. In fact, LegalZoom specifically states that in its disclaimer. Summarizing LegalZoom’s own disclaimer:

    1. The employees of LegalZoom are not acting as your attorney.

 

    1. LegalZoom’s legal document service is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney.

 

    1. LegalZoom does not review your answers for legal sufficiency, draw legal conclusions, provide legal advice or apply the law to the facts of your particular situation.

 

  1. The legal information on LegalZoom’s website is not guaranteed to be correct, complete or up-to-date.

Do-it-yourself estate planning is risky

The problem is that the documents LegalZoom creates could be completely ineffective.

People who use LegalZoom and other do-it-yourself estate planning kits end up with a false sense of security. They create documents that they believe will address their estate planning needs. But with estate planning documents, they are unlikely to discover their mistakes.

Why? Because the mistakes will not become evident until after they become incapacitated or die. And the people who will be left to deal with the mistakes are usually the people the documents were supposed to protect.

You and your loved-ones deserve the advice of a lawyer who considers the facts of your particular situation. You deserve legal advice that is correct, complete and up-to-date. LegalZoom by its own admission does not provide that.

The bottom line

The money you save now could be spent many times over after you die to address legal issues about which you were not even aware.

Attorneys don’t simply fill in forms. Rather, we use the knowledge we have acquired during our many years of schooling and practice to advise you on the best way to protect your family, and preserve and distribute your assets in the manner you choose.

Your loved-ones are worth it. Wouldn’t you agree?

Comments

  1. Could not agree more. In fact, I have blogged about why you shouldn’t use DIY services for forming corporations. http://nclawlife.com/2009/02/06/seven-things-diy-corporations/
    http://nclawlife.com/2009/01/14/do-you-really-need-a-lawyer-to-form-your-corporation/

    And once you’ve made some poor decisions because you were unwilling to pay for competent advice on the front end, it usually costs more to fix it on the back end.

  2. Excellent post. I’ve been telling clients this for years. It’s the nuances of estate planning law that will get them in trouble, and lack of understanding the legal context for the documents, like how property is titled, beneficiary designations, etc. Clients need a qualified lawyer to sit down with them and look at the big picture, or they risk not getting the results they expect.

  3. Rania, the nice thing about your virtual law practice is that people can get access to the customized legal services they need, with the convenience of an on line service and at a price they can afford.

  4. David Errington says:

    I am an Ohio estate planning attorney and took LegalZoom for a spin to see what they had to offer. As Ms. Combs stated, I found outdated law and misleading advice that could really cause some problems down the road. Like Stephen Bloom stated above, there is no context. For instance, you could certainly establish a testamentary trust in their will but who will be administering it? Are they aware that there will be ongoing yearly costs for filings with the probate court? Would establishing a living trust make more sense? You get the idea.

    On top of that, the fee they would charge a married couple for Wills is actually not that much less than what I charge. And, by LegalZoom’s own admission, they are not providing legal advice (although I think they have actually crossed the line to UPL). As I tell people that ask me about LegalZoom, using an attorney doesn’t guarantee that it will be done perfectly, but it certainly increases the likelihood that it will be correct and, if it isn’t, at least attorneys have malpractice insurance.

  5. I am glad to not only hear of the Legal Zoom issues, but see it in print. The most important ‘Product’ from an attorney is the intellect, experience and not a cost savings. The law is not a commodity.

    Thank you. I enjoyed reading this article.

    George Shipe, senior Vice President
    NATIONAL BENEFIT ADVISORY, INC.
    Bremerton, WA.

Trackbacks

  1. […] documents.  The do-it-yourself route includes LegalZoom and Quicken.  Notably, there has been a strong backlash against LegalZoom for guiding people to improper decisions and creating wills that, in the end, reach probate. […]

  2. Inspired Solos: Rania Combs - The Texas Wills and Trusts Online Blog says:

    […] Rania’s already seen some return on her hard work. Her stats are up, she’s being featured in the Texas Bar Journal’s monthly newsletter “Weblinks” section this month (where she kindly gave The Inspired Solo a little love!), and she’s been approached by a few outlets to contribute content. She’s also getting some retweet love on Twitter for her blog posts, and got a Blawg Review mention after just a few weeks of blogging for one of her most-publicized and well-received posts, “The Problem With LegalZoom.” […]

  3. My Shingle says:

    To Win the Hearts and Minds of Consumers, Lawyers Need to Sell, Not Sue…

    To date, lawyers haven’t been able to effectively sell the public on the idea that document preparation services like Legal Zoom are a poor substitute for the services of a lawyer. So, being lawyers, they’ve done the next best thing……

  4. […] answer is, perhaps, yes and no. As the following blog posts from Rania Combs at texaswillandtrustlaw.com illustrate, potential DIYers must recognize the limitations of, well, doing it […]

  5. […] Rania Combs: The Problem with LegalZoom (And Other Do-It-Yourself Estate Planning Solutions) […]

  6. […] wills and trusts – sure it could work out, but I'd rather just go to a lawyer in the first place. The Problem with LegalZoom — Texas Wills and Trusts Law Online http://altmanassociates.com/wp-conte…angers_HD1.pdf Especially in your case where you are […]

  7. […] Rania Combs: The Problem with LegalZoom (And Other Do-It-Yourself Estate Planning Solutions) […]

  8. […] understand that while you can use a do-it-yourself legal website to create these documents yourself, it is very easy to make a mistake. If those mistakes affect your business pursuits, you may end up paying more in legal fees down the […]

  9. […] The law is constantly changing. Every quarter there are hundreds of new statutes passed by state governments and Congress, not to mention changes in case law from judge’s decisions. All of these laws can affect your business, and only lawyers who specialize in that particular type of law (business law, trusts and estates planning, personal injury, etc.) can advise you—and draft your unique documents—appropriately given those recent changes. More on this here. […]

  10. […] The law is constantly changing. Every quarter there are hundreds of new statutes passed by state governments and Congress, not to mention changes in case law from judge’s decisions. All of these laws can affect your business, and only lawyers who specialize in that particular type of law (business law, trusts and estates planning, personal injury, etc.) can advise you—and draft your unique documents—appropriately given those recent changes. More on this here. […]

  11. […] if you prefer: “Online Legal Documents Company Sued Over Flawed Estate Plan“; “The Problem with LegalZoom (And Other Do-It-Yourself Estate Planning Solutions)” or “Do It Yourself Estate […]

Leave a Comment

If you would like to add your perspective to this post or have a general question, please leave a comment. However, if you have a fact-specific legal question, please email me, or communicate with me through my secure client area. To do so, simply login if you are an existing client, or request an introductory conference if you are interested in becoming a new client.